After four insightful months, Ryan Heise ends his Dinner With Android and draws a conclusion:
I approached this experiment with a lot of questions, the primary of which was quite simple: why do people use Android? I had my own preconceived answers — they dislike Apple or couldn’t get an iPhone for one reason or another — but I dove in with an open mind regardless. After over four months of Android 2.3 on a Nexus S, I’m left mostly answerless. [...] To be frank, I still don’t know who Android is for.
He also offers a great analogy about the UX of the two OS’s:
iOS feels like a manual transmission being operated by a seasoned driver. Android is a dumb teenager constantly dropping the clutch, and seemingly getting more and more frustrated as time goes on.
I keep saying that I’m fine with people using Android, as long as they don’t try to convince other people to use it – if one doesn’t already know about it, the differences between Andriod and iOS and the advantages of the former, than one’s not in the group of people that actually benefits from those advantages. That is to say, only people that enjoy tinkering with and reading about their gadgets benefit from Android more than from iOS. Or as Ryan puts it:
I know there are people who simply choose to use it, and I accept that. I don’t really care. But I just can’t wrap my head around any of the arguments that come up in support of it.
So can’t any customer that isn’t tech-savvy and interested in the technology behind those devices enough to read up on them before going into a shop to actually buy one of them.
This wrap-up is an excellent read, and while a lot of Android-fans might not agree with everything in it, it’s about as objective as one can get. I envy Ryan for his experience, and while I’m not going to go Android-only for any amount of time, I’m still hoping that some day, some manufacturer will step up and offer an an Android-equivalent of the iPod touch that is actually somewhat easy to get and not crap spec-wise, plus has the Market Place so that I can further back my thoughts of Android with actual experiences.
